SpeechPathology.com Phone: 800-242-5183

Med Travelers - December 2019

In One Ear and Out the Other - What Patients Remember

In One Ear and Out the Other - What Patients Remember
Robert H. Margolis
January 5, 2004

Editor's Note: Although this article was originally written for www.audiologyonline.com and clearly addresses the audiology professionals, I believe there is a plethora of applicable and important material here for the SLP too. Dr. Margolis has graciously allowed us to publish this article here too. Sincerely, ---Dr. Douglas L. Beck

In Meredith Willson's The Music Man, Mayor Shinn announces to the July 4th crowd in the River City High School Madison Auditorium, "Members of the school board will now present a patriotic tableau." Up jumps a school board member who whispers in the Mayor's ear and the Mayor corrects himself: "Members of the school board will not present a patriotic tableau."

Nine out of ten semantic units were correct. The scene shows how easily the loss of one information unit can completely change the message. Can't you just see the Iowa farmer with noise-induced hearing loss from years in the tractor seat wondering why he is being subjected to Eulalie McKecknie Shinn's impersonation of a Grecian urn instead of the promised patriotic tableau?

How often do our patients miss one or two critical facts resulting in a complete misunderstanding of their communicative problem and what to do about it? This question gnawed at me for years until I came to the conclusion that every important fact or recommendation that is given to a patient should be given in writing, in an easily understood format that can be shared with family members, read, reread, and kept for future reference.

I recently saw a patient who is an intelligent professional and had been seen previously by two audiologists. I know the audiologists well and I don't believe it is possible that they did not thoroughly and clearly explain the results. After I discussed the findings and provided the results and recommendations in a clear, written format, the patient thanked me and said no one had ever explained that before. I think he forgot.

We need to keep in mind that our patients lead busy lives and there are many things that work against the likelihood that they will remember what we tell them. The working mom whose son broke an ankle yesterday playing soccer, who is worried about missing work for just a hearing evaluation, who doesn't have anything for dinner tonight, and whose husband may be laid off next week, might not remember the difference between a conductive loss and a sensorineural loss. And when relating the information to her husband that night, "Your hearing will probably not get better" can easily become "Your hearing will probably now get better." Most of the semantic units were correct.

Recently it occurred to me that ours is not the only field with information that is important for patients to understand and remember. I consulted the Audiology counseling literature but found only one study of patient recall following audiologic consultation and a brief reference to the issue in Luterman's excellent text on Counseling Persons with Communication Disorders and Their Families (Austin: Pro-Ed, 2001). I was shocked that Audiology, a communication profession, has almost completely neglected to be concerned with the effectiveness of our communication of information to patients. Other professions have addressed the issue and there are many research studies and discussions of patient recall in the medical literature, most by British authors. A list of references can be found at www.audiologyincorporated.com.

Robert H. Margolis

Related Courses

Brain Health Basics: Strategies for SLPs to Support Healthy Aging for Adult Patients
Presented by Megan L. Malone, MA, CCC-SLP, Jennifer Loehr, MA, CCC-SLP
Course: #9785Level: Introductory1 Hour
This Back to Basics course focuses on the preventative aspect of improving brain health with adult patients, with emphasis on elements that SLPs can target during instruction or counseling aspects of patient treatment and caregiver support. Additional information is provided on advocacy for these services and community outreach to organizations working with older adults.

Young Children's Negative Attitudes toward Peers with Communication Disorders: What SLPs can do to help
Presented by Mary Weidner, PhD, CCC-SLP
Course: #8764Level: Introductory1 Hour
At a young age, children with communication disorders are at high risk for social punishment from their communicatively typical peers. This course will provide an overview of the emergence of bias in young children, explain the impact of negative attitudes on children with communication disorders, and offer recommendations on how to productively address negative peer attitudes.

Providing Support to Families of Children with Hearing Loss
Presented by Jane Madell, PhD, CCC-A/SLP, LSLS Cert AVT
Course: #9043Level: Introductory1 Hour
Families of children with hearing loss present with unique needs and challenges. Families’ issues commonly center around accepting hearing loss as well as planning management. Children need support regarding social, emotional and academic development. Hearing loss may impact speech, language, listening, reading, and learning – skills that are critical during childhood years and beyond. The impact of hearing loss on children and families is individual but there are many common challenges even for those with the most access to resources and support.This course will present information and resources for social workers, speech-language pathologists, audiologists, school personnel, therapists and other professionals to support them in their work with families of children with hearing loss.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Health Care: It's Not Just Black and White - Mental Health Care
Presented by Susan Holmes-Walker, PhD, RN
Course: #1033811Level: Intermediate1 Hour
This course is the first in a 3-part series that addresses diversity, equity, and inclusion in healthcare. This course focuses on mental health care and the impact of implicit bias in service delivery. In addition, tools for facilitating and implementing effective diversity and inclusion initiatives are discussed, along with their challenges and positive effects on outcomes.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion in Health Care: It's Not Just Black and White - Disabilities
Presented by Susan Holmes-Walker, PhD, RN
Course: #1033812Level: Intermediate1 Hour
This course is the second in a 3-part series that addresses diversity, equity, & inclusion in healthcare. It focuses on disabilities and the impact of implicit bias on service delivery, and discusses the importance of the representation of people with disabilities as health care professionals and how this affects the quality of patient care. In addition, tools for facilitating and implementing effective diversity and inclusion initiatives are provided.

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.