SpeechPathology.com Phone: 800-242-5183


Progressus Therapy

Ethical Issues in Dysphagia Management

Ethical Issues in Dysphagia Management
Lynne Brady Wagner, MA, CCC-SLP
January 18, 2016
Share:

When I was a new clinician in the early 1990s, I worked in a hospital setting and was very interested in the care of individuals who had swallowing problems.  I was fortunate to be in a great setting during my clinical fellowship year and learned a great deal about the clinical techniques, management, and approaches for diet recommendations and swallowing programs for patients. However, I struggled with the challenges of how to manage when a person who was demonstrating aspiration or risk for aspiration would refuse a recommendation for a diet modification or for an alternative nutrition and hydration approach – even if just for a temporary period of time to help them get over their illness.  Those were the kinds of things that we had not delved into enough in my graduate program at the time.  These are things that we all learn when we get out into the professional setting. 

I would like to talk about approaches that are helpful for cases that we struggle with, and discuss a paradigm or way of looking at a particular question. Then you can apply it to the next question that comes up, to determine if this case is similar or different from the one that you just dealt with. What was your approach or the collective approach in that situation, and can you apply it to this case?  If not, what is different and what else can you think about? 

Ethics – Overview and Definitions

Ethical Dilemmas

What is ethics and what is an ethical dilemma?  One of the first and most important things that we need to do is to figure out how to define what an ethical dilemma is, versus what a clinical dilemma is.  What is a clinical question or dilemma?  Those are the challenges we are faced with in terms of the patient’s diagnosis and prognosis; their cultural backgrounds, belief systems, cognitive abilities, etc., that help us to choose a clinical approach and clinical recommendations for patients.  An ethical dilemma is choosing between two or more options; sometimes they can be two good options, but more often, they are two bad options.  However, we are thinking about the good approach, and what is the right approach, for a patient. 

There is an excellent book on clinical ethics written by the late John Fletcher, Introduction to Clinical Ethics (1997). He says, “Hegel, in his short essay on logic, reasoned that the headachy business of choosing between one good and another, or obversely between one evil and another, is true tragedy, whereas the simplistic collision of good and evil - black and white - is only melodrama.”  These are the types of challenges that we deal with in our clinical care where there is not one right answer.  There is not one right approach to the situation. 

Very often, when people approach an ethical dilemma and they think that they may want to involve consultation with an ethics advisory committee, they believe that the ethics committee will tell them what the right approach is; or perhaps they believe that the committee will come in and tell a member of the team that they are taking the wrong approach in that situation.  In fact, to do a true ethics analysis is to identify the range of ethically acceptable options in terms of what is good for the patient, based on our current cultural values and norms.


lynne brady wagner

Lynne Brady Wagner, MA, CCC-SLP

Lynne Brady Wagner is the Program Director of Stroke Rehabilitation and the Chair of the Ethics Advisory Committee at Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts.  After earning a masters degree in Speech-Language Pathology from Saint Louis University, Lynne began her career in Chicago and worked at the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago (RIC) where she became the Resource Clinician for Adult Dysphagia. She has a graduate certificate in Health Care Ethics from Rush University Medical School and was the first Disability Ethics Fellow at RIC and the MacLean Center for Clinical Medical Ethics at the University of Chicago.  Lynne is a former member of ASHA’s Board of Ethics and in the past has been the Ethics Column editor for the Special Interest Group 13 (Swallowing and Swallowing Disorders) Perspectives.  She currently serves as the Coordinator of the Coordinating Committee for SIG 13 and is an instructor at the MGH Institute for Health Professions where she teaches Healthcare Ethics.



Related Courses

Dysphagia in Neurodegenerative Disease
Presented by Debra M. Suiter, PhD, CCC-SLP, BCS-S
Video
Course: #9732Level: Intermediate1 Hour
Dysphagia is common in individuals with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and Parkinson’s disease. This course discusses the underlying pathophysiology and appropriate treatment programs for each disease, as well as use of alternate methods of nutrition/hydration.

Ethical and Legal Issues in Dysphagia Management, Part 1
Presented by Denise Dougherty, MA, SLP
Video
Course: #9027Level: Intermediate1 Hour
This is Part 1 of a two-part series. This course will review specific aspects of ASHA's Code of Ethics that are related to dysphagia. It will also discuss how to complete a thorough dysphagia evaluation, including chart review, clinical evaluation, justification of therapy services and documentation. (Part 2 - Course 9084)

Treating in the Gray Zone: Post-Acute Care Considerations
Presented by Melissa Collier, MS, CCC-SLP, CHC, CDP
Video
Course: #10066Level: Intermediate1 Hour
This course helps post-acute care clinicians better understand how to approach treatment when things aren’t black and white. It addresses scenarios such as geriatric frailty/weight loss and diet modification, the paradigm shift to a patient-choice model, legal considerations regarding diet waivers, and the care plan process. The SLP's role on the post-acute interdisciplinary team is also discussed.

Ethical and Legal Issues in Dysphagia Management - Part 2
Presented by Denise Dougherty, MA, SLP
Video
Course: #9050Level: Intermediate1 Hour
This is Part 2 of a two-part series. Speech-language pathologists involved in dysphagia evaluation and therapy face many challenges, such as how to handle a patient/family that does not agree with the recommendations. This course will address ethical and legal considerations when working with this type of client, including ethical concerns with waivers and patient-centered plans of care. (Part 1 - Course 9069)

Decision Making for Alternate Nutrition and Hydration - Part 1
Presented by Denise Dougherty, MA, SLP
Video
Course: #9581Level: Intermediate1 Hour
This is Part 1 of a two-part series about alternate nutrition and hydration (ANH). This course reviews patient and family concerns that impact the ANH decision-making process, including religious beliefs and culture. Advance directives are discussed and resources for patients/families are provided.

Our site uses cookies to improve your experience. By using our site, you agree to our Privacy Policy.