SpeechPathology.com Phone: 800-242-5183


Global Teletherapy - Remote Therapy Experts - April 2021

Doing More With Less for People With Aphasia: Creative Responses to Healthcare Change

Doing More With Less for People With Aphasia: Creative Responses to Healthcare Change
Candace P. Vickers, PhD, CCC-SLP
January 7, 2003
Share:

 

Speech language pathologists providing therapy services to persons with aphasia in medical settings are confronted today with two seemingly incompatible grim realities: 1) Persons with aphasia often have limited access to rehabilitation due to limited visits allowed by managed care insurances and; 2) third party payers, supervisors and families of persons with aphasia expect 'functional outcomes' as a result of treatment regardless of the time frame allowed. At the same time ASHA's revised Scope of Practice for Speech Language Pathology (May, 2001) now states that the ultimate goal of speech-language therapy intervention is to improve quality of life via increased participation in life.

The call to increasing 'life participation in aphasia' was initially sounded by some of the top aphasiologists in the country (Lyon, 1992; Chapey, et al, 2000). Increasing 'participation in life' may seem like a lofty task to the average clinician toiling away in a medical setting when, with shorter treatment sessions, the number of patients seen in a day has increased, paperwork has doubled, and obtaining even six to twelve consecutive visits for treatment can require a Herculean effort from clinicians already short on planning time.

Facing up to why it is important to "do more with less" 

Doing "more with less" for people with aphasia begins with the SLP's recognition that months and months of individual speech and language therapy possibly never has necessarily been the road to increased communication opportunities, communication success, and/or participation in life for persons who have aphasia. The profession shares some responsibility in not clearly demonstrating the functional effectiveness of therapy in the typical medical setting under typical conditions. How, for example, can it be suggested that twelve individual therapy sessions are too few, when it has not been fully demonstrated that 40 sessions produced real life meaningful changes in persons' lives? (Threats, 2002)

One response to the constraints imposed by today's healthcare system is to do as Roberta Elman has suggested (1999) and provide treatment "outside the box." The "box" that clinicians may need to step out of could be what Jon Lyon (1999) calls the box of 'reimbursable care'. Both Elman and Lyon are dedicated aphasiologists who actually did step "out of the box" to forge new frontiers in meeting the communication needs of people with aphasia. Elman and her colleagues Bernstein-Ellis and Ewing, left paying jobs as speech language pathologists to begin the Aphasia Center of California in Oakland, which offers group therapy to people with aphasia five days a week without billing third party payers. Lyon partners with community agencies to train "communication partner volunteers" to provide services to people with aphasia through his nonprofit organization, Living with Aphasia. He also provides long term specialized services to couples coping with aphasia that would be unavailable in traditional treatment settings. ( Lyon, 1999) Providing services that empower couples coping with aphasia to learn more efficient communication strategies is to be applauded and hopefully taken up by more speech-language pathologists. For example, Boles (1998, 2000) has reported measurable changes in communicative success for couples who received Solution Focused Aphasia Therapy in the university setting. It is crucial, however, that clinicians in traditional medical settings are also able to show the effectiveness in facilitation of real life functional changes in the lives of those with aphasia. The current reduced treatment time situation for speech-language pathologists is precarious since not achieving functional goals with decreased therapy time could be used to declare that therapy does not really work. The continuing challenge for clinicians providing aphasia therapy in the medical arena will not only be to advocate for patients to receive the appropriate amount of treatment visits, but also to initiate at least beginning guidance for coping with the long term consequences of aphasia on daily life. This process can begin through family education and training in the initial stages of therapy, but will also need to address ensuring that persons with aphasia have access to meaningful communication opportunities such as that provided by participation in group conversation programs that focus on facilitating satisfying interactions with peers and trained volunteers.

 

candace p vickers

Candace P. Vickers, PhD, CCC-SLP

Dr. Candace Vickers is the author of Communication Recovery: Group Conversation Activities for Adults (1998). In 1994 she created and initiated the Communication Recovery groups, which use trained communication partners in groups for persons with aphasia at St. Jude Medical Center. Candace has 30 years experience in treatment of aphasia and other neurogenic communication disorders and has been a National Aphasia Association State Representative for the last ten years. In addition to her work with outpatients at St. Jude Medical Center, Candace is an adjunct faculty member at both Chapman University California State University, Fullerton in Southern California. She conducts research, writes about and presents in the areas of group therapy, use of trained volunteers, partner training in aphasia and a social networks approach to aphasia assessment and therapy.



Related Courses

Best Practice for Assessment and Treatment of Bilingual Aphasia
Presented by Maria Muñoz, PhD, CCC-SLP
Video
Course: #9759Level: Intermediate1.5 Hour
This course focuses on best practice in the assessment and treatment of bilingual aphasia by speech-language pathologists. Recommended practices are contrasted against common mistakes made by clinicians working with bilingual patients with aphasia. Implementation of best practices are modeled through case studies.

20Q: Goal and Treatment Selection in Aphasia in 20 Sessions or Less
Presented by Jackie Hinckley, PhD, CCC-SLP
Text
Course: #9281Level: Intermediate1 Hour
Have you ever wondered how to focus aphasia therapy and set reasonable goals when treatment time is limited? This course will provide evidence-based guidance on goal-setting and treatment selection for aphasia with examples from time-limited situations.

Evidence-Based Practice: Leading to Evolution of New Treatment Approaches for Aphasia
Presented by Emily Boss, MS, CCC-SLP
Video
Course: #8293Level: Intermediate1.5 Hour
This is Part 1 of a two-part series. This course reviews evidence-based practice and provides an overview of relevant theory for the development of a new semantically-based sentence-level treatment approach for persons with aphasia: Semantic Priming to Improve Comprehension and Expression of Sentences (SPICES). (Part 2: Course 8296)

Interpreting Test Scores & Key Concepts with Standardized Tests
Presented by Carolyn (Carney) Sotto, PhD, CCC-SLP
Video
Course: #8295Level: Intermediate1 Hour
Many of the assessment instruments we use are norm-referenced tests that are standardized. There are certain statistical properties needed to understand the psychometric criteria of the tests, which is part of being an informed consumer. This course will help SLPs understand fundamental concepts of descriptive statistics so they can interpret test scores correctly and summarize quantitative data about their clients or patients.

Clinical Application of Evidence-Based Practice in Aphasia: SPICES
Presented by Alyssa Autenreith, MA, CCC-SLP
Video
Course: #8296Level: Intermediate1.5 Hour
This is Part 2 of a two-part series. This course reviews evidence-based practice and provides step-by-step training of a new semantically-based, sentence-level treatment approach for persons with aphasia: Semantic Priming to Improve Comprehension and Expression of Sentences (SPICES). (Part 1: Course 8293)