SpeechPathology.com Phone: 800-242-5183


EBS - The world has changed 2 - March 2021

Ethical Dilemma and Ethical Distress

Lynne Brady Wagner, MA, CCC-SLP

January 19, 2016

Share:

Question

What is an ethical dilemma and how is it different from ethical distress?

Answer

To answer this question, it is important to understand the difference between an ethical dilemma and a clinical dilemma.  Clinical dilemmas are challenges or factors related to a patient’s diagnosis or prognosis. For example, cultural background, belief systems, cognitive abilities, etc. help us choose a clinical approach and clinical recommendations for a patient.  An ethical dilemma is choosing between two or more options; sometimes they can be two good options, but more often, they are two bad options.  However, we are thinking about what the right approach is for a patient. 

How is this different from moral distress or ethical distress?  There are many times when we face true ethical dilemmas, but more often, the feeling of concern we have for a particular situation is defined as “moral distress”. Moral distress is not uncommon when we have a team-based approach, because each team member will approach a situation different due to the type of relationship they have with the patient, as well as the different responsibilities, different scopes of practice, different licensure, different educational backgrounds, and differing knowledge about the facts of the situation.  We have distress when we are in a situation where we feel like we know that the right action or right course is not happening.  For example, a decision has been made for a patient and we do not feel it is the right one, but we do not have the locus of authority in that situation to make those decisions. This often causes a scenario called moral distress.  Hamrick, who is an ethicist and nurse in Virginia, has written about this and indicates that ethical distress often affects nurses and resident physicians. Being in a position of carrying out the orders of the primary provider on the team and not agreeing with the particular approach can create moral distress.  It is important that we recognize that, and figure out how to manage those situations. 

Lynne Brady Wagner is the Program Director of Stroke Rehabilitation and the Chair of the Ethics Advisory Committee at Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts. 


lynne brady wagner

Lynne Brady Wagner, MA, CCC-SLP

Lynne Brady Wagner is the Program Director of Stroke Rehabilitation and the Chair of the Ethics Advisory Committee at Spaulding Rehabilitation Hospital in Boston, Massachusetts.  After earning a masters degree in Speech-Language Pathology from Saint Louis University, Lynne began her career in Chicago and worked at the Rehabilitation Institute of Chicago (RIC) where she became the Resource Clinician for Adult Dysphagia. She has a graduate certificate in Health Care Ethics from Rush University Medical School and was the first Disability Ethics Fellow at RIC and the MacLean Center for Clinical Medical Ethics at the University of Chicago.  Lynne is a former member of ASHA’s Board of Ethics and in the past has been the Ethics Column editor for the Special Interest Group 13 (Swallowing and Swallowing Disorders) Perspectives.  She currently serves as the Coordinator of the Coordinating Committee for SIG 13 and is an instructor at the MGH Institute for Health Professions where she teaches Healthcare Ethics.


Related Courses

20Q: Ethical Issues Associated with the Supervisory Process
Presented by Wren Newman, SLP.D, CCC-SLP
Text

Presenter

Wren Newman, SLP.D, CCC-SLP
Course: #8459Level: Intermediate0.5 Hours
  'good refresher'   Read Reviews
This course provides information regarding the responsibility of supervisors to ensure that their supervisees do not engage in unethical behavior. It also provides information on what supervisors should do when they discover that their supervisees have violated standards of ethics.

Ethical Considerations When Working with Those who Stutter
Presented by Lisa R. LaSalle, PhD, CCC-SLP
Video

Presenter

Lisa R. LaSalle, PhD, CCC-SLP
Course: #8991Level: Intermediate1.5 Hour
  'It heightened my knowledge about an important subject'   Read Reviews
This course will discuss how the stigma of stuttering, advocacy, empathy, caseload management, and the structure of various settings in which we work (e.g., schools, medical settings, university clinics) impact our work with people who stutter, across the lifespan. Case scenarios involving ethics and stuttering will be presented for participants' consideration.

Ethical Practice in Aging Care
Presented by Amber B. Heape, ClinScD, CCC-SLP, CDP
Video

Presenter

Amber B. Heape, ClinScD, CCC-SLP, CDP
Course: #8755Level: Introductory1 Hour
  'Excellent and concise explanations of each principle followed up with clear examples of each'   Read Reviews
As healthcare and reimbursement are changing, therapists often find themselves facing questions of ethics when working with clients who are aging. This course will review the principles of bioethics and how they apply to SLPs working with aging adults. Decision-making scenarios will be presented and discussed for application of knowledge.

Ethical and Legal Issues in Dysphagia Management, Part 1
Presented by Denise Dougherty, MA, SLP
Video

Presenter

Denise Dougherty, MA, SLP
Course: #9027Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'This course provided good information on how to perform dysphagia treatment and assessment in an ethical manner'   Read Reviews
This is Part 1 of a two-part series. This course will review specific aspects of ASHA's Code of Ethics that are related to dysphagia. It will also discuss how to complete a thorough dysphagia evaluation, including chart review, clinical evaluation, justification of therapy services and documentation. (Part 2 - Course 9084)

Ethical and Legal Issues in Dysphagia Management - Part 2
Presented by Denise Dougherty, MA, SLP
Video

Presenter

Denise Dougherty, MA, SLP
Course: #9050Level: Intermediate1 Hour
  'Emphasis on education'   Read Reviews
This is Part 2 of a two-part series. Speech-language pathologists involved in dysphagia evaluation and therapy face many challenges, such as how to handle a patient/family that does not agree with the recommendations. This course will address ethical and legal considerations when working with this type of client, including ethical concerns with waivers and patient-centered plans of care. (Part 1 - Course 9069)